| Was
Guru Nanak Dev Ji a muslim ? |
| |
|
|
When Guru Nanak Dev Ji had his first communion
with God, God blessed him and sent him to this world to spread His
message, the first words uttered by Guru Sahib Ji was “There
is no Hindu, there is no Mussalmaan,” from the outset Guru
Sahib Ji distanced himself from these faiths as both were lacking.
Many times in Guru Sahib Jis bani the mussalmaan is admonished and
chastised for his bigoted nature.
Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born into a Hindu family but rejected its
rituals and customs, Guru Ji was blessed with two sons, Sri Chand
Ji and Lakhmi Das Ji, hardly muslim names, his father was Mehta
Kalu and mother was Mata Tripta Ji. Guru Nanak Dev Ji enjoyed
the company of holy persons, be they Hindu or muslim this did
not matter because Guru Ji recognised the divine spirit present
in all.
He did not dress like a muslim as some people try to portray
, Guru sahib Ji dressed as a holy man, which meant a chola of
khuddar (rough low grade material) and a pair of wooden sandals
or Kharama.
On his travels Guru Sahib Ji did travel eastwards, but never
to a Hajj. Guru Ji had previously travelled to Hardward, Benaras,
Varanasi, and other places of Hindu and Buddhist pilgrimage, this
hardly makes him a Hindu or a Buddhist, wherever he went he put
people on the True path of God. As for Mecca, Guru Sahib Ji slept
deliberately with his feet towards the Kaaba. When challenged
by the local Imam, Guru Ji replied “point my feet where
God is not.” Upon moving Guru Ji’s around so that
his feet faced the other way the Imam found to his surprise that
Guru Ji’s feet were still pointing towards the Kaaba. He
did it again and again the feet were pointing to the Kaaba, thus
showing that God resided everywhere and that is was our foolish
and bigoted minds that saw him in one place or set of people.
Hardly the actions of a Muslim.
On Guru Ji’s travels through Bhagdad his companion Mardana
would play the rabab and Guru Sahib Ji would sing about the infiniteness
of God and His Creation, wherein occurred the following expression:
“ there
are numerous patals (earths) and innumerable akashs (sky).”
|
|
when some
Muslim who was listening to it realised what was being sung (the
Qu'ran mentions only seven earths and seven skies) he reported
the blasphemy to the Sajjdanashin of the Shrine of Pir Dastagir,
Abdul Qadir Jilani.
Meanwhile
an agitated crowd gathered on the spot. The people were on the
verge of throwing stones when they heard the Guru’s divine
invocation. The people in remorse went to their Pir and told him
of the presence of a holy man.The Pir, having reached the place,
enquired from Mardana who the holy man was. He was told that he
was Nanak who had rejected all others except one God who was all
pervading on earth, sky and in all four directions. Guru Nanak
Dev Ji had many discourses with the holy men and they were convinced
that Guru Ji was truly and man of God.
Before his
departure Guru Ji was presented with a chola (robe) as a token
of respect and the high regard the holy men held Him, on which
verses in Arabic were inscribed. This chola lies preserved in
the Gurdwara at Dera Baba Nanak, in Pakistan. The chola was given
to Guru Sahib Ji by his devotees in Bagdhad and Guru Sahib Ji
took it in the spirit in which it was given, no more. Pir Babhol,
a Sufi saint was also deeply influenced by Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
So this notion that the robe and its inscriptions hold any more
significance is just incorrect.
Upon Guru
Ji’s travels Guru Nanak kept a pothi (small book) in which
were written down all shabads composed by him, these were kept
safe and handed down to the subsequent Gurus. Guru Nanak Dev Ji
was well educated and conversant in Hindi, Persian, Fasri and
Sanskrit, he was no illiterate, and the words of Guru Nanak Dev
Ji can be relied upon to be 100% accurate as the message of the
Almighty. Guru Ji never carried the Koran or a prayer mat, why
would he? He had rejected Islam from the outset.
When at Mecca
the local Imam asked Guru Sahib Ji to do kalma with him. As the
Imam started his kalma Guru Ji did not, and stood to one side.
Upon finishing, the Imam in his fury asked Guru Ji the meaning
of this, Guru Ji said to him “what is the use of meaningless
ritual when your mind was someplace else trying to work out how
to get the best price for your horses.” The Imam was shamed.
|
|
| |
| |
The
Q'uran holds no significance for a Sikh.
Fasting holds no relevance to a Sikh.
Circumcision mutilation holds no relevance to a Sikh.
Sikhs do not go in for ritual slaughter of innocent animals.
Sikhs do not face in any particular direction, east or west, when
praying.
Sikhs do not hold any significance in ritual shaving of the head.
Sikhs do not hold any significance in throwing stones at a pillar. |
|
 |
The
word "al-Taqiyaa" means: "Concealing
or disguising one's beliefs, convictions, ideas, feelings, opinions,
and strategies." In Arabic the translation is "hypocrisy
in the pursuit of a greater purpose." And this word "al
Taqqiyaa" gives its followers religious authorisation
to tell lies even if it contradicts what is stated in the Q'uran
and Hadiths if it means one can bring someone into the fold. So,
when reading or debating please be aware of this tactic. |
|
|
|
| |
|
Guru Nanak Dev Ji, was the greatest
teacher of the world who brought forward true knowledge and made no compromises
in his principles. Guru Ji found the prevailing thoughts of the time to
be a seething mass of moral putrefaction. He detected among their elements
rituals and superstition, and he struck at the root of these problems
by demanding truth in faith and spirit in worship. Guru Ji cleared away
everything that inhibited the relationship between God and human. Guru
Ji held out no promises in this world or even in the next world. Guru
Ji taught that the idea of life, the measure of salvation, is not happiness
or peace of mind. To serve God and be able to love Him is in itself better
than happiness, though it may be with wounded feet, bleeding brows, and
laden with sorrow.
Guru
Nanak Dev Ji separated Vedantic philosophy from religion, and declared
it to be a mere gymnastics of the mind. Guru Ji showed that religion is
less a matter of intellect and more a matter of spirit. The practice of
Yoga may do very well for emptying the mind of desires, but it only gives
a negative result. Guru Nanak Dev Ji substituted music, the singing of
God's praises (Shabad Kirtan), for meaningless rituals as a means of linking
the soul of humans with God.
Guru
Nanak Dev Ji also helped greatly improve existing spiritual rules of conduct.
There are two sorts of duties: (1) what we ought to do and (2) what we
ought not to do. World religions had very early recognized the latter.
"Thou shall NOT kill and Thou shall NOT do this or that.....this
was all that was understood by the word Dharma or duty. This emphasis
on the negative side of virtue led to the adoption of asceticism in the
east as the highest ideal of life, which ultimately means the negation
of all manly duty. Guru Nanak Dev Ji preached a higher truth. To him love
was active service, and his disciples soon profited from this teaching.
There is no higher record of service in history than that shown by the
Sikhs, who were taught to annihilate the thought of self and utilize all
their energy in the service of God and humility. No one loved God and
humanity more than Guru Nanak Dev Ji. By the Guru's grace, may we all
be blessed to carry Guru Nanak Dev Ji's mission into the future.
|
| Why
did Guru Nanak's own son abandon Sikhism? |
| |
|
|
| Guru
Nanak Dev Ji he was blessed with two sons, born around 1491 and
1494, Sri Chand and Lakhmi Das. Baba Sri Chand was a very spiritual
person and Guru Nanak Dev Ji could see that he had chosen a path
of quiet contemplation on the Almighty and did not care much for
worldly affairs this played a part in the Guruship being passed
on to Bhai Lehna Ji. This is not to say that Baba Sri Chand abandoned
Sikhism. In fact the Gurus right up to the sixth Guru, Guru Hargobind
Sahib Ji showed the utmost respect for Baba Sri Chand Ji. On one
visit Baba Sri Chand asked Guru Hargobind Sahib for something to
link him and his followers to the Sikh Panth for eternity. Guru
Hargobind in his divine wisdom then gave Sri Chand his son Baba
Gurditta, who is revered as the successor of Baba Sri Chands order.
Thus, Baba Sri Chand did not reject Sikhi.
|
|
It
is sometimes stated that Guru Nanak Dev Ji abandoned his family
on his long Udassis (journeys). This is not true. Guru Nanak Dev
Ji was a devoted father and husband and cared and provided for his
family. Guru Sahib Ji was married when he was about fifteen years
old as was the custom of the times. By the time of the first udassi
Guru Sahib Ji was around thirty years old and his two sons were
around ten years old. So the early years were spent looking after
and providing for the family, when the call came form God to spread
His name across the lands Guru Sahib Ji placed his family in the
care of his parents and extended family, also his elder sister Nanaki
Ji and husband who lived in nearby Sultanpur were instructed to
keep an eye on Mata Tripta Ji and the two little ones. So, in no
why did Guru Sahib Ji neglect his duties as a householder. In fact
Guru Sahib Ji showed practically how to juggle the duel roles of
worldly and family affairs.
|
|
| |
| If
God is everywhere like Sikhism says, then is God inside you when you're
on the toilet? Is he in you when you commit adultery , fornicate , drink
alcoho l, smoke? |
| |
|
|
|
God is everywhere. He is within each and every
one of us, he is in the animals and the plants. He is in the sea
and in the very air that we breathe. Like a fish cannot live without
water, we cannot live without God. God did not create this world
and then step back from it, He is actively involved in everything
that we do.
|
|
God
watches over us when we do good and when we do bad. God is also
with us when we perform our bodily functions, why shouldn’t
he be? He created us and the way we are so why would he leave
us? A mother is not disgusted when her child goes to the bathroom,
in fact she cleaned and cared for him for many years with love
and devotion so why would God, the father of all humanity , feel
any different about his children? |
|
| |
| |
Var
by Bhai Gurdaas Ji
The Lord is the fragrance in flowers, the becoming black bee He is
attracted towards flowers.
Sap in the mangoes is He and becoming nightingale He enjoys the same.
Becoming peacock and the rain bird (babiha) only He identifies the
delight in raining of the clouds.
He transforms Himself into variegated sweets by becoming milk and
water.
The same Formless Lord assuming different forms is residing in all
the bodies.
He is Omnipresent in all substances and activities and gurmukhs bow
before all of His such stages. |
|
 |
|
|
Many
faiths regard God as some far of entity who has created this world
but resides separate from it. They look up to the skies to find
Him, they renounce everything and wonder off into the wilderness
in search of Him, they face a particular direction in the hope of
winning favour with Him. But what they do not realise it the very
thing they are looking for is in fact residing within themselves.
|
|
Guru
Gobind Singh Ji says in his Akal Ustat :
By Thy Grace. Laghu Niraaj, stanza
O Lord! Thou art water. O Lord! Thou art dry land. O Lord! Thou
art the stream. O Lord ! Thou art the Ocean. 13.63
O Lord! Thou art the tree. O Lord! Thou art the leaf. O Lord ! Thou
art the earth. O Lord ! Thou art the sky. 14. 64.
O Lord! I meditate on Thee. O Lord! I meditate on Thee. O Lord!
I repeat Thy Name. O Lord ! I worship Thee. 15.65.
|
|
| |
|
|
| As
is the reflection in the mirror, He sees in the world His ownself.
That perfect Lord is there in all the selves; the ignorant individual
searches Him outside as the moon sees its own reflection in the
water and feels it is there.
Lord Himself is there in the milk, cow and ghee.
Taking fragrance from the flowers He Himself is the flavour in them.
His own phenomenon is there in wood, fire, water, earth and snow.
The perfect Lord resides in all the selves and is visualised only
by a rare Gurmukh.
Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa
|
|
Since
God resides everywhere, then to Him nothing is sacred and nothing
is unholy, nothing is clean and nothing is dirty, for He resides
in all things. It follows that God is with you when you are doing
good and when you are doing bad.
|
|
| |
|
| Sikhism
talks a lot about time-wasting rituals. Aren't the 5 Ks just a big ritual? |
| |
|
|
Gurmat
is against all blind rituals that have no meaning. The 5 K’s
were given to us by our Guru as our external identity.
By simply wearing any article of clothing will not make us a better
person, but a person who is living an internal spiritual discipline,
the outer uniform helps reinforce that commitment. We are all
affiliated to someone or something, the 5K’s is our commitment
to uphold the ideals of our Gurus.
|
|
There are many kinds of rituals some may call
these meaningless also : Fasting, facing in a particular direction
when praying, slaughtering an innocent animal in the name of God,
shaving ones head, throwing pebbles at a stone pillar, offering
water to your ancestors and snip snip of the circumcision ( ouch
yaar !)
|
|
| |
| |
Guru
Nanak Dev Ji in Siree Raag on Pannaa 75
The Lord's Name is not within your heart, but all sorts of other tastes
seem sweet to you.
You have no wisdom at all, no meditation, no virtue or self-discipline;
in falsehood, you are caught in cycle of birth and death.
Pilgrimages, fasts, purification and self-discipline are of no use,
nor are rituals, religious ceremonies or empty worship.
O Nanak, emancipation comes only by loving devotional worship; through
duality, people are engrossed in duality. ||2|| |
|
|
| Sikhs
revere a false scripture not a revelation from God. Bhagats and Saints
have contributed to the Guru Granth Sahib proof that this is not from
God, but from the collective writings of men. |
| |
|
|
| Guru
Granth Sahib Ji is a divinely revealed scripture. There are many
occasions when this is made clear in Guru Granth Sahib Ji :
jaisee
mai aavai khusum kee baanee thaisurraa kuree giaan vae laalo ||
As the Word of the Forgiving Lord comes to me, so do I express
it, O Lalo. (p722).
sathigur
kee baanee sath sath kar jaanuhu gurasikhuhu har kuruthaa aap
muhuhu kudtaaeae ||
O GurSikhs, know that the Bani, the Word of the True Guru, is
true, absolutely true. The Creator Lord Himself causes the Guru
to chant it. (p308)
There
are many more examples where it is made clear that the bani in
Guru Granth Sahib is the word of God.
In
Guru Granth Sahib Ji, there is also the bani composed through
different bhatts (bards) and bhagats who were Sikhs of the Guru
and inspired to recite as well. The Bhatts were given initiation
by the Guru and although they were a wandering group of minstrels,
they ended up staying with the Guru for the rest of their lives,
singing his praises. They describe the mystical experiences and
sights they've seen and show how amazing and great Guru Nanak
is. Let us not forget that the Bhagats were no ordinary men, their
spirituality was of the highest order and their Bhagat bani in
Guru Granth sahib Ji is not found in any of their own collections.
For example, Bhagat Kabir's bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji is not
found in his Beejak or any of his collected works, it is unique
to Guru Granth Sahib Ji because it is the word of God. |
|
The Bani they recited after becoming Sikhs is the one in Guru
Granth Sahib Ji and not found in any of their works.
The
notion that the Gurus ‘borrowed’ from other religious
texts in also false. The Gurus bani rejects time and time again
all other religious texts, so why would it include passages from
them? The belief that Guru Granth Sahib contains any passages
from other religious texts or translations of them is totally
false. Guru Arjun Dev Ji personally overlooked all aspects of
the compilation of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and whose shabads are
the most. These were direct revelations from God as was all the
bani from all the Gurus and Bhagats.
This
is very much contrary to some other texts that was compiled many
years after the prophet ascended the heavens. In fact the prophet
was illiterate so how could he have written down or understood
any alleged revelations to him?
Actually
the Sahib Siri Guru Granth sahib is the only religious composition
written by its prophets, i.e. The Guru’s themselves.
No
other religion can claim this. The Koran was written not by a
prophet, but 50 years after Mohammed passed away. Mohammed himself
was illiterate, so did not write anything. But the kabba and the
Hajj is also a form of big idol worship. The Bible was written
by the gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, none of them contemporaries
of Jesus and written at least 50-100 years after Jesus.
|
|
| |
| |
Guru
Amar Daas Ji in Siree Raag on Pannaa 35
In speaking, in seeing and in words, remain immersed in the Shabad.
The Word of the Guru's Bani vibrates throughout the four ages. As
Truth, it teaches Truth.
Egotism and possessiveness are eliminated, and the True One absorbs
them into Himself.
Those who remain lovingly absorbed in the True One see the Mansion
of His Presence close at hand. ||3|| |
|
| |
Guru Granth Sahib
Ji does not narrate the life story of Guru Nanak Dev Ji , but each and
every word is dedicated to the Glory of the Almighty Divine Being only.
It is not a reproduction of earlier religions, but the Divine Word (Gurbani)
came to the Gurus, and 15 Bhagats, 17 Bards, & 4 devotees (who all
shared the same Dharam of Naam & Gurmat), direct from God. Guru
Nanak Ji stated that it was not his philosophy, it was not his understanding
and it was not his thinking, but the Word was coming to him direct from
God and he was simply delivering His message to the world. As he confirms:
|
| |
'O
Lalo, as comes the Divine Word from the Lord to me, So do I narrate
it.' (Raag Tilang Mohalla 1, p-722)
'I have said what Thou commandeth me to
say.' (Raag Wadhans Mohalla 1,p-566)
This was repeatedly confirmed and emphasized by
all the Gurus in their Bani such as:
'From God springs ambrosial Gurbani The
exalted Guru narrates and preaches the same to the world.' (Raag
Majh Mohalla 3, p-125)
'This Word comes from Him, Who hath created
the World.' (Mohalla 4, p-306)
'This Word that hath come from God, It dispelleth
all woes and worries.' (Raag Sorath Mohalla 5, p-628)
'I speak but the Will of the Lord, For the
Lord's devotee narrateth the Word of the Lord.'(Raag Sorath
Mohalla 5, p-629)
'Whatever the Lord hath instructed me, Hear,
O my brother.' Raag Tilang Mohalla 9, p-727)
The tenth Master, Guru Gobind Singh Ji established
the same truth that it was God's Word that was being revealed through
the Gurus:
'Whatever
the Lord sayeth to me I say the same to the world.' (Guru
Gobind Singh Ji )
|
|
| |
|
Guru Granth Sahib Ji was not written by the devotees
after the Gurus had gone, but it was dictated and compiled by the Gurus
themselves. Thus it is the Authentic Divine Scripture. No body is allowed
to change even a comma or a period out of 1430 angs (pages). The Seventh
Nanak's son, Ram Rai, changed the meaning of only one verse to please
the Emperor, Aurangzeb, upon which he was excommunicated for ever by his
father (the Seventh Nanak), thereby establishing the fact that no one
could ever change the God's Word, the Gurbani.
Guru Granth Sahib Ji is numerically structured which
acts as a central locking system. The numerical system ensures that no-one
can add their own hymn or Bani into the Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The poetic
beauty of Guru Granth Sahib ji ensures that no person can add an extra
word to the Guru Granth Sahib, which would disrupt the flowing poetry.
The Tenth Nanak made five copies of the Guru Granth Sahib Ji which he
dictated and signed. One Volume was taken by Ahmed Shah Abdali and the
whereabouts is unknown. However the other four Volumes are preserved at
the Takhat Sahibaans (Sri Hazoor Sahib, Sri Patna Sahib, Sri Akaal Takhat
Sahib, & Sri Kesgharh Sahib).
Max Arthur Macauliffe, an English writer, delivered a speech at Akal Bunga,
Amritsar in 1899:
"There
is another point to the merit of the Sikh religion that the founders of
other religions in this world never wrote even one line with their own
hands. You might have heard that there was a very famous Greek philosopher
called Pythagoras who had many followers, but he never left behind anything
written by him from which we could have known about the principles of
his sect. After him came the second Greek philosopher named Socrates who
was born in 500 B.C. He became a very famous religious leader who claimed
that he was receiving Divine instructions from God within himself, which
persuaded him to do good and prohibited from doing any evil deeds. But
he too never left anything behind written by him which could have shed
light on his philosophy and its principles. Whatever we know about him,
has only come through the writings of his follower, Plato. Besides there
came Mahatma Buddh in India and he never wrote anything with his hands.
Then came Christ who did not write anything himself either. His teachings
are only known through the Bible which was written by others. Then came
Muhammad who was illiterate who also did not write down anything. However
the Sikh Gurus acted quite opposite to all these religious leaders that
they themselves dictated their message of Truth and compiled Guru Granth
Sahib. In this respect the Sikh religion is far ahead than others."
|
|
| The
semitic books and the Koran give plenty of prophocies, in fact they take
great pride in their so called prophocies, what about Sikhism? |
| |
|
|
Sikhism
is not in the business of making prophecies, we leave this up
to the charlatans, the conjurers, the tricksters, the Nosrtodamus
type fraudsters. Sikhism is not impressed with prophecies and
miracles to win over new converts.
|
|
The
Guru's insisted that the message should speak for itself. Although
Sikh history is filled with amazing miracles, they were not done
for show purposes or to impress. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is not a
book of prophecies, it is a scripture that leads one to the realisation
of God and inspires love and tolerance.
|
|
| |
| Here are a few questions to ponder over. When a religion of a billion
followers attacks and tries to undermine a faith with 25 million disciples
then the word that comes through loud and clear is - INSECURITY. A person
whoes own foundations are shaky will |
| |
|
|
Some
information has been added by kind permission of |
"WhyIchoseSikhism." |
|
| |
|